Z wrote on Aug 9, 2007 5:33 PM:
" The man who brought this rug home is a truely astonishing individual who redifines words like honor, valor, and pride. The truth of this story can never be told until this Lt. Col. can explain the deep symbolism and sense of timing the rug holds. Its currently held in Fort Bragg's JFK Special Forces Museum where the soldiers who faught over there can appreciate the value of a humble Afgani who acknowledges the hard work of our soldiers. God bless men like Lt. Col. Gile who works so compassiately with civil affairs. "
Zaffos wrote on Aug 9, 2007 5:32 PM:
" The man who brought this rug home is a truely astonishing individual who redifines words like honor, valor, and pride. The truth of this story can never be told until this Lt. Col. can explain the deep symbolism and sense of timing the rug holds. Its currently held in Fort Bragg's JFK Special Forces Museum where the soldiers who faught over there can appreciate the value of a humble Afgani who acknowledges the hard work of our soldiers. God bless men like Lt. Col. Gile who works so compassiately with civil affairs. "
Sheila from CA wrote on Jul 26, 2006 7:08 PM:
" To Bullsai,
Would you rather be popular or important? I think we know which answer Bush would choose.
Historians will be far more sophisticated in judging this President than the current so called sophisticated elite of today. The Daily Kos and their ilk are just haters. I repeat they are just like the people that vilified Lincoln. I believe Bush is on the right side of history.
"
bullsai wrote on Jul 24, 2006 1:53 PM:
" Sheila from CA, of course he's the worst president ever! Look at his aproval rating. His ridiculous lies about why we were taken to war with these countries has hurt our people and our soldiers more than any other president. If you want more proof, got to google, type in the word failure, and click "I'm feeling lucky", and see what happens. "
bullsai wrote on Jul 24, 2006 1:48 PM:
" Sheila from CA, of course he's the worst president ever! Look at his aproval rating. His ridiculous lies about why we were taken to war with these countries has hurt our people and our soldiers more than any other president. If you want more proof, got to google, type in the word failure, and click "I'm feeling lucky", and see what happens. "
Grayson Gile wrote on Jul 24, 2006 1:04 PM:
" This rug, the accounts, and the heartfelt thanks extended by the Afghan gentleman who made this heart-felt gift of thanks and are genuine. Should "Know Better" and "Herrin High" have the intenstinal fortitude to call me, accurately identify themselves by name, and intelligently discuss their concerns/accusations, I will be more than happy to discuss the issue-Grayson Gile "
John Ruhmann wrote on Jul 23, 2006 7:16 PM:
" A man is only as good as his word. He's one Good man. "
SFC Antonio M. Barini wrote on Jul 23, 2006 10:56 AM:
" I spent a year in Afghanistan (2005-2006) as an Embedded Tactical Trainer to the Afghan Army. I trained and served in combat with Aghan soldiers in Sharan Paktika Province and Narai Kunar Province. I fully understand the danger this man put himself in, to accomplish this great task. In my experience with the Afghan people he speaks for the majority and his gift made with love, gratitute and humility should be honored by all of us. It would be a tragity if LT Col Gile where not able to deliver it to President Bush, but it would be the greatest and most unforgiveable insult should it end up in a warehouse or never reach the Presidents posession. "
Know Better wrote on Jul 23, 2006 10:41 AM:
" I know this states atty: this whole story is bull. "
Walter Sobchak wrote on Jul 22, 2006 12:20 PM:
" Had me the ringer, chop chop!! "
Lesley wrote on Jul 21, 2006 1:38 PM:
" Amazing. May God bless the man who made this rug.
Lesley, Texas "
Ah the hateful left wrote on Jul 21, 2006 11:38 AM:
" showing once again how much they just don't get it.
"
Sheila from CA wrote on Jul 21, 2006 10:56 AM:
" Bush the worst President ever?? I don’t think so. Your idiotic remarks are right up there with the people who vilified Abraham Lincoln during the civil war.
History, the Roman historian Livy said, is the best medicine for a troubled mind.
So take your medicine and get well soon.
"
Herrin High wrote on Jul 21, 2006 10:42 AM:
" I have my doubts as to whether this rug and the story behind it are genuine. Can the State’s Attorney lay a better foundation before we admit the rug as evidence? I think this story’s a whopper with too many unanswered questions. I also agree the thing is downright creepy – especial with Mr. Decider frocked up like a priest. The fact that many of your readers like this thing and are praising it is another disturbing sign of how fast we are sliding into a theocracy in this country. We already have a de facto religious test for holding office. What’s next? This is the sort of thing the Founders of this country were trying to get away from. I also wonder if the State’s Attorney is feathering his own political nest on this one. Does he plan to use this in a bid for higher office or is he trying to shore up his standing with the far right? Makes you wonder. "
The Dear Leader, appreciative? HA!!! wrote on Jul 21, 2006 6:57 AM:
" Since when does chimpeachable Georgie boy ever show appreciattion?
He is a smug, arrogant, meglomaniac type of "person"
The guy who made this may be appreciative but and many of you say the worst president ever should accept this rug etc. How bout Chimpy start dressing the way he is depicted> How bout he start telling which religion to start-paying taxes to.
See dumbya never went to church till becoming president made it imparative that he do so. It is a pony show. Many seem so fooled by this " "man" however, sinclair lewis said it best, "When fascism comes to america it will be wrapped in the flag, carrying a cross."
Worst president EVER.
"
JMU_Katie wrote on Jul 21, 2006 12:11 AM:
" For all those out there who believe we do not belong over there, here is just one great story of a man who appreciates our efforts. Countless men and women are thankful for the actions our president and military have taken. We should take this and remember how much it meant to this man before war bashing and complaining. "
Zelda wrote on Jul 20, 2006 11:58 PM:
" What a sweet man. It's a terrible shame the leftists are too bitter and hateful to appreciate such a beautiful, thoughtful gesture. It is so sad they can't put politics aside to see this moment as one of healing and friendship between cultures. "
Helium Rat wrote on Jul 20, 2006 4:19 PM:
" Anyobody know where I can find a larger image of the rug, in more detail?
Google avails me not. "
you're not right wrote on Jul 20, 2006 1:39 PM:
" The "it's not right" comment is extremely offensive. You have all the mainstream media on your side not telling the truth, you don't need to degrade this story. Why is it so hard to believe that there are many people free in this world due to the United States and that some are actually grateful. I have read many stories (although they are not put in mainstream media) of families who have had loved ones die and are proud of what they did.
I am sure you would be happier living in Venezuala, or someplace similar. "
its not right wrote on Jul 20, 2006 5:31 AM:
" how many people lost their life for that rug?
i would have thrown it away
we dont belong there....just because one person is greatful doesnt mean the whole country is.
ask the faimlys of our soldiers who are dead because of a car bobmb.
"
DB - Florida wrote on Jul 19, 2006 8:20 PM:
" The story is very moving, and President Bush, I think, would feel pesonally honored and grateful. My concern is for the man who made it. It sould seem as though it wouldn't be so hard to track down someone with talent such as this, being an older person, knowing his religious preference, and the town he was from. Won't his enemies know how to find him? "
Henry IX wrote on Jul 19, 2006 6:20 PM:
" Notice how Al Franken's comment has nothing to do with the story.
I think it is very significant that a man in Afghanistan would be so impressed with Mr. Bush that he went to all the work of making the rug. He deserves our thanks, and I hope that Mr. Bush will express his own thanks. "
Al Franken wrote on Jul 19, 2006 3:02 PM:
" I can tell from the comments that Southern Illinois Bible Thumpers are happy with the story. My definition of a Bible Thumper: Fire-and-brimstone yelling, Bible waiving, holier-than-thou, sinners who think they live a better life than you AND other Bible Thumpers!
I think it is wonderful that our president has strong religious beliefs, but I do not approve of him "wearing them on his sleeve" at government events. I think his religious beliefs need to guide his personal conduct (I am sure it does), not guide the U.S. Government. (It goes against the interpreted concept of our founding fathers about separation of church and state).
Bring on your comments, ye ole Bible Thumpers!! "
student wrote on Jul 19, 2006 1:32 PM:
" I hope that when that makes it to the White House it will be prominently displayed. It is definitely a unique and important gift to the United States!I also hope the main stream media picks it up. "
Debi A Angel wrote on Jul 19, 2006 1:02 PM:
" This is one of the most refreshing stories that I have been given the opportunity to read. President Bush needs to be recognized for the great gifts he has enabled or soldiers to provide to the locals during this time of turmoil. So often President Bush is criticized for his actions and his decision to go to war more often President Bush should be acknowledged for his determination to stick to his choices and provide a better life for others not as fortunate as we Americans. It is far easier to criticize when people do not understand instead of seeing the whole picture and saying thank you for your commitments. "
Lee wrote on Jul 19, 2006 11:40 AM:
" A greaat article. I'm glad it was sent to me by e-mail. I'm sure the media, except Foxx, maybe, will ever give it the light of day. Our gratitude and respect for this man's efforts are truly heartfelt "
Gale wrote on Jul 19, 2006 10:37 AM:
" I think this is wonderful and shows they appreciate us helping. Very courageous of that rug maker. This rug should be placed in a place of honor and the President should accept it personally. "
The Dude wrote on Jul 19, 2006 8:06 AM:
" The rug really ties the room together man. "
Odd-duck wrote on Jul 18, 2006 10:38 PM:
" Notice how sinfully silent the liberals are about this? I'm sure it is gnawing at their jaws that they don't have the stones to run down this story. "
rds wrote on Jul 18, 2006 6:41 PM:
" Extremely touching. I hope that rug is put in a place of honor somewhere. "
Mike C wrote on Jul 18, 2006 5:26 PM:
" The people of France did the same thing when they (as opposed to some government giving 'charity') gave us the statue of liberty. They paid for it with their own money, not the French government. "
randomfreak wrote on Jul 18, 2006 2:51 PM:
" That is awesome! I know I couldn't take a year to make a gift for someone, even if they had pretty much saved my life. "
Tamie Cruse, Tacoma WA. wrote on Jul 18, 2006 2:35 PM:
" This is amazing. I wish our people could pull together and see how good America can be. Others see it, why can't we all? "
Bill wrote on Jul 18, 2006 12:25 PM:
" If it is the same man from Chicken Street, I bought a rug from the same man in '03. He was Hazara and we told him about JC. "
Mike O wrote on Jul 18, 2006 8:12 AM:
" Not something you'll see in the NYT or the WaPo, but should. Thank you for this story. "
Sharon Church wrote on Jul 18, 2006 6:17 AM:
" This is a very moving story. I know our President will be touched. Hope there will be a follow-up to this story. "
Leonard Johnson wrote on Jul 17, 2006 11:45 PM:
" Many, many thanks for publishing this story. I doubt that many Americans will learn about this amazing gesture of gratitude, as most likely the NYTimes and Assoc. Press, and network TV "news" departments will ignore it. "
That is... wrote on Jul 17, 2006 11:43 PM:
" ...one of the spookiest things I have ever seen. "
Barrie wrote on Jul 17, 2006 6:01 PM:
" I'm an Australian, and I hope this heartwarming and unusual story gets a good run in our press and yours, which are very slow with good news in the war on terror.
They can't say that it doesn't have a good visual to accompany it!
I'll tip off our local papers. "
Doc DuBois wrote on Jul 17, 2006 11:16 AM:
" That is a very beautiful & respectful
rug. Some people do show respect & gratitude to some people. We all should do the same. Thank GOD. "